All Episodes

Have You Seen This?! The Murder Tapes, S2E5, Is That Blood?

Feb. 25, 2021

What happened to 29 year old missing mom, Danielle Pruett? Police in Tazewell, Virginia use the city’s traffic and business surveillance systems to piece together the final shocking moments of her life.

File 71: The Fatty Arbuckle Scandal and The Murder of Fred Oesterreich

Feb. 24, 2021

Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle was an accomplished silent film actor, director, and screenwriter when a scandal involving the death of an up-and-coming movie starlet derailed his career in 1921. Just a year later, the murder of wealthy textile manufacturer, Fred Oesterreich exposed a bizarre love affair b…

Have You Seen This?! Dead Silent, S3E5, Taken For a Ride

Feb. 11, 2021

Who could have murdered 23 year old Jacey McWilliams in Middleburg, Florida? Between the few suspects that turn up, one starts to stand out, and you won’t believe his motive!

File 70: Elderly Murderers Melissa Shepard and Ray Copeland

Feb. 10, 2021

Melissa Shepard, also known as the Internet Black Widow, is responsible for poisoning 3 men and attempting to kill one more. Ray Copeland shot at least five men in the back of the head on the Missouri farm he shared with wife Faye, with seven more victims possible.

Have You Seen This?! Obsession: Dark Desires S2E5 Occult Following

Feb. 4, 2021

When Krystal Dragan agrees to go on a Wiccan-themed public access TV show, she doesn’t realize how deep into obsession the host will become, and how her life will never be the same.

File 69: Arsonists Bruce Lee and Thomas Sweatt

Feb. 3, 2021

Bruce George Peter Lee is Britain’s most prolific serial killer with 26 arson murders attributed to him. In the US, Thomas Sweatt is credited as being the State’s worst serial arsonist with 350 fires set, but fortunately, he was only able to murder 3 people. Join us this week as Sherrie and Josh di…

Have You Seen This?! Crime Stories S7E3

Jan. 28, 2021

Successful businesswoman Tara Lynn Grant goes missing after an argument with her husband in 2007. Could she have flown back to her job site  in Puerto Rico or did something more sinister happen to her?

File 68: The Frankford Slasher and The Sims Family Murder

Jan. 27, 2021

Hey guys, remote recording is hard! So please forgive my audio in this episode. I promise I’ll try to crawl out of my barrel real soon.   - S

Have You Seen This?! Murder In Paradise S1E3

Jan. 21, 2021

What happened to Rick Post who disappeared from Baja Mexico in 1998? Was he the target of a drug cartel or someone closer to home? Find out this week as we recap and review season 1, episode 3 of Murder In Paradise, Spies, Lies, and Alibis .

File 67: The Snowtown Murders and The Kidnapping of Ursula Herrmann

Jan. 20, 2021

In 1999 police discover 8 bodies in plastic barrels in an abandoned bank in Snowtown, South Australia. Four more victims are later tied to the killers, but who are they and what was their motive? In Eching, Germany in 1981, 10 year old Ursula Herrmann doesn’t come home after dinner at her cousins h…

Have You Seen This?! Nightmare Next Door S9/E2

Jan. 14, 2021

Who killed popular businessman Bob Eidman in St Charles, Minnesota in 2007? Was it his wife, upset about an affair,  a business rival who stole a client, or could it have been a complete stranger? Find out who is responsible this week as we recap and review season 9, episode 2 of Nightmare Next Doo…

File 66: The 2011 Tucson Shooting and The Palm Sunday Massacre

Jan. 13, 2021

In 2011, a man opened fire in a shopping center in Tucson, Arizona, killing 6 people and wounding 13 others, including US Representative Gabrielle Giffords. In 1984, 10 people were gunned down in their apartment in East New York on Palm Sunday. Two women and eight children were murdered as they rel…

Have You Seen This?! Killer In Plain Sight S1E2

Jan. 7, 2021

Who killed 16 year old Dinah Peterson on Valentine’s Day in 1975? Was it her forbidden older boyfriend, her angry dad, or her jealous friend?  The case goes cold for 30 years before new detectives take a fresh look and an arrest is made.

File 65: The Disappearances of The Martin Family and Jayme Closs

Jan. 6, 2021

In 1958, the Martin family set out one Sunday afternoon to the Columbia River Gorge to gather greenery for Christmas decorations.  They were never seen alive again. In 2018, 13 year old Jayme Closs was abducted after an intruder murdered her parents, but she survived the ordeal. Tune in this week a…

File 64: H.H.Holmes and Belle Gunness

Dec. 30, 2020

One more Patreon file to tide you over till Josh and Sherrie come back from the holidays. In this episode Josh explores whether the notorious serial killer H.H. Holmes could have been the secret identity of Jack the Ripper and Sherrie tells the gruesome story of the murderess Belle Gunness.

File 63: Patreon Bonus Episode - Party Monster Michael Alig and Serial Killer Clifford Olson

Dec. 23, 2020

Please enjoy one of our earlier Patreon episodes while we take a holiday break to spend time with family! “On this month’s Patreon episode, Josh covers the murder of Angel Melendez by Michael Alig and Robert “Freeze” Riggs, all members of New York’s party scene in the 1990’s, then Sherrie delves in…

Have You See This?! The 1990’s: The Deadliest Decade S1E6

Dec. 9, 2020

Millionaire Frank Griga and his girlfriend Krisztina Furton go missing from Golden Beach, Miami, Florida in 1995. When their Lamborghini is found abandoned in the Everglades National Park, investigators realize it may already be too late to find the couple alive. Audio clips courtesy of (in order o…

File 62: The Survival Stories of Vicky Cilliers and Jennifer Asbenson

Dec. 8, 2020

Vicky Cilliers is an avid skydiver with more than 2,500 jumps under her belt. But when both of her chutes fail on a jump in 2015, she plummets 4,000 feet to the ground. She miraculously survives but the incident begs the question, was this an accident or a brutal act of sabotage? In 1992, Jennifer …