All Episodes

File 31: Serial Killers Dorothea Puente and Carlton Gary

May 5, 2020

This week we cover 2 serial killers who have very different motivations, Dorothea Puente and Carlton Gary.

Have You Seen This?! Cold Case Files S1E3

April 30, 2020

Who stabbed and murdered 14 year old Tina Faelz as she was walking home from school in 1984? Was it a notorious school bully, her mother's violent boyfriend, or one of several serial killers that were operating in the area at the time? Find out as Josh and Sherrie review episode 3 from season 1 of …

File 30: The Torture Murders of Suzanne Capper, Fan Man-yee, and Channon Christian and Chris Newsome

April 28, 2020

Torture is on the table and we want to put up a trigger warning for this week's episode where we tell the horrific stories of the murders of Suzanne Capper, who was murdered by her so-called friends, then Fan Man-yee, in the famous Hello Kitty murder, and finally, Channon Christian and Chris Newsom…

Have You Seen This?! Swamp Murders S3E2

April 22, 2020

Who was responsible for the disappearance and murder of Suzie Knuth who went missing in 1980?  Was it her adoring husband or was it a random kidnapping?  This week, Josh and Sherrie discuss this case of whodunit from season 3, episode 2 of Swamp Murders.

File 29: Stalking Leads to the Deaths of Laurie Show and Cotton Kelly

April 21, 2020

We have two cases of stalking this week (and Josh relays his own story).  First up is the stalking and murder of Laurie Show then we cover the stalking and many murders in the life of Sandy Shaw.  Thanks for listening!

Have You Seen This?! Web of Lies S6E7

April 15, 2020

Rannita (Nunu) Williams thought that Jonathan Robinson would be the love of her life but when another women enters the picture, things go downhill quickly, and publicly.  This week we cover this case of murder caught on Facebook live and highlighted on the series Web of Lies, season 6, episode 7.

File 28: The Wrongful Convictions of Kimberly Long and Kristine Bunch

April 14, 2020

Our two cases this week focus on wrongful convictions. First up is Kimberly Long who was convicted of killing her boyfriend, Oswald Conde when, in fact, she had only happened upon his body.  Who was the real murderer? Then we cover the case of Kristine Bunch who spent 17 years in jail for the death…

File 27: Angels of Death Donald Harvey and Charles Cullen

April 7, 2020

Angels of Death are the topic this week and we cover the two cases of Donald Harvey and Charles Cullen, both of whom abused their power in healthcare to commit the ultimate crime.

Have You Seen This?! Nurses Who Kill S1E4

April 7, 2020

Today we discuss Daniela Poggiali, an Italian nurse who thought it was hilarious to take pictures of herself with deceased patients.  Patients who she was accused of murdering with potassium chloride.  We review this case from season 1, episode 4 of the Netflix series Nurses Who Kill.

Have You Seen This?! See No Evil S3E8

April 1, 2020

This week we review the episode The Doctor Will See You from the ID channel series, See No Evil which focus on cases that are solved with the use of CCTV. In this case, Dr. David Cornbleet is brutally murdered in his dermatology office and his killer is caught on camera.

File 26: The Stabbing Murders of Euronymous and The Hollywood Ripper

March 31, 2020

We cover two stories of stabbings this week, on two different continents. The first is the murder of Euronymous of the Norwegian black metal scene and the second is serial killer Michael Gargiulo, dubbed The Hollywood Ripper.

Have You Seen This?! Casey Anthony's Parents Speak

March 25, 2020

We all know the story of Casey Anthony, who was suspected of murdering her two year old daughter, Caylee.  This week we cover the A&E documentary Casey Anthony's Parents Speak to see how George and Cindy are dealing with the tragedy 10 years later.

File 25: Women Who Kill Their Family: Christy Sheats and Jolly Thomas

March 24, 2020

In this episode we discuss women who kill their families.  Christy Sheats murdered her two daughters in Texas and Jolly Thomas killed 6 of her family members over a 14 year period in Kerala, India.

Have You Seen This?! The Family I Had

March 18, 2020

This week we review the documentary, The Family I Had which tells the story of the horrific murder of four year old Ella Bennett by her own brother, Paris.

File 24: Cowboy Murders!

March 17, 2020

Two cowboys, 150 years apart, both murderers.  This week we discuss the crimes of Levi Boone Helm and "Cowboy" Mike Braae.

Have You Seen This?! Wives with Knives S1E1

March 11, 2020

This week we review an episode from season 1 of Wives with Knives, The Beefcake and the Beauty Queen.  This case is about the tumultuous marriage of  Charlie Czerniawski (the beefcake) and Jamie Silverstrone (the beauty queen).

File 23: The Murder of Maddie Clifton

March 10, 2020

Maddie Clifton was an eight year girl who disappeared from Jacksonville, Florida in 1998.  In this episode, we discuss what happened to her and the unusual circumstances of her discovery.

Have You Seen This?! Evil Lives Here S7E2

March 4, 2020

The week we are reviewing episode 2 from season 7 of Evil Lives Here: I Raised a Sociopath.  This episode tells the story of Robert Foust's struggles raising his sociopathic son, Aaron and how he's had to deal with the aftermath of his son committing the ultimate crime.