Episodes

Have You Seen This?! Obsession: Dark Desires S1E10

June 24, 2020

Kathleen Gallagher Baty has had a stalker for going on 10 years and things come to a head one evening when her husband is out of town and the stalker sneaks into her home. Find out what happens in the final showdown as we review season 1, episode 10 of Obsession: Dark Desires, Crushed . Support th…

File 38: The Murders of Britney Cosby and Crystal Jackson and the Murder of Barry Winchell

June 23, 2020

Britney Cosby and Crystal Jackson were a black lesbian couple who were brutally murdered in 2014 and Barry Winchell was a US Army soldier who was beaten to death 15 years earlier in 1999. Listen in as Sherrie and Josh discuss who killed these innocent victims in the prime of their lives. Support t…

Have You Seen This?! A Crime To Remember, S2E5

June 17, 2020

Two sisters go missing from Tucson in 1965 and the police have to decide if a former love interest is to blame or could one of the rowdy "Speedway Kids" be responsible. Find out what happened as we review episode 5 from season 2 of A Crime To Remember. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/user…

File 37: Colin Ireland - The Gay Slayer and the Upstairs Lounge Arson Massacre

June 16, 2020

Colin Ireland decided he wanted to be famous so he became a serial killer and intentionally murdered five gay men in London in 1993. Twenty years earlier, Roger Nunez set a fire in the Upstairs Lounge, a popular gay hangout, and 32 people perished, but did he mean to be a murderer or was it a drunk…

Have You Seen This?! People Magazine Investigates S3E10

June 10, 2020

In 1965 Holly Maddux left her conservative family in small town Texas to pursue a more liberal lifestyle at college in Philadelphia. But only 12 years later, Holly goes missing, leaving behind a family desperate for answers. Find out what happened to Holly as we review season 3, episode 10 of Peop…

The Murder of Kenneth Zeller and the Pulse Nightclub Massacre

June 9, 2020

In honor of Pride Month, Sherrie and Josh will be covering cases of crimes against the LGBTQ community. This week, Sherrie covers the murder of Kenneth Zellner in Toronoto in 1985 and Josh talks about the 2016 Pulse Nightclub massacre in Orlando, Florida. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/…

Have You Seen This?! Fear Thy Neighbor. S6 E3

June 3, 2020

A feud between neighbors ends in murder. What happened to cause the patriarch of the Fuller family to declare all out war on the Copelands? This week we review season Fear Thy Neighbor, season 6 Episode 3, House of Shards . Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=25398556)

File 35: Jeffrey Dahmer and Vince Li

June 2, 2020

The cannibals Jeffrey Dahmer and Vince Li and their motives are discussed. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=25398556)

Have You Seen This?! Trial By Media, S1E1

May 27, 2020

Why does someone get murdered after an appearance on The Jenny Jones Show in 1995? This week we will review the first episode of the new Netflix show, Trial By Media, Talk Show Murder, and discuss the circumstances of the murder and the role that media may have played. Support the show (https://ww…

File 34: Unusual Murder Weapons in the Murders of Stefan Andersson and Ramon Novarro

May 26, 2020

When we think of murder we often assume the weapon used was one of three traditional ones: gun, knife, or hands, but people can use any object to commit the ultimate crime. This week Josh and Sherrie discuss two cases where unusual weapons were used to take someones life, Stefan Andersson and Ramon…

Have You Seen This?! Southern Gothic S1E3

May 20, 2020

Who murdered Michael Reese in his own home one Wednesday night right after he got back from church? The police are dying to know because his house is right next door to their station, so it seems too bold to be a burglar and much more likely that it was someone he knew. Find out the shocking truth …

File 33: Murder by Poisoning

May 19, 2020

This week we cover two cases of people who resorted to murder by poisoning for financial gain in addition to the terrifying unsolved case of the Chicago Tylenol murders. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=25398556)

Have You Seen This?! If I Should Die S1E3

May 13, 2020

What happened to Conrad and Ricky Morales? These two brothers were dealt an unfair lot when they were sent to live with their uncle then one goes missing and the other one ends up dead. This week we review season 1, episode 3 of If I Should Die, The Lost Boys. Support the show (https://www.patreo…

File 32: The Disappearance of Two Dutch Students in Panama and the Jodi Huisentruit Story

May 12, 2020

This week Sherrie discusses the unusual disappearance of Lisanne Froon and Kris Kremers, two Dutch students who were on a cultural trip to Panama and disappeared in the thick jungle. Then Josh tells us the story of the origin of the Amber Alert and then the probable abduction and disappearance of …

Have You Seen This?! Blood Runs Cold S1E3

May 6, 2020

When Jessica Dishon goes missing one day, leaving behind her cell phone, purse, and one shoe, the local sheriff is sure that she is just a runaway. That is, until her body is found two weeks later down by the local high school hangout. Josh and Sherrie review this case that is featured on season …

File 31: Serial Killers Dorothea Puente and Carlton Gary

May 5, 2020

This week we cover 2 serial killers who have very different motivations, Dorothea Puente and Carlton Gary. Support the show (https://www.patreon.com/user?u=25398556)

Have You Seen This?! Cold Case Files S1E3

April 30, 2020

Who stabbed and murdered 14 year old Tina Faelz as she was walking home from school in 1984? Was it a notorious school bully, her mother's violent boyfriend, or one of several serial killers that were operating in the area at the time? Find out as Josh and Sherrie review episode 3 from season 1 of …

File 30: The Torture Murders of Suzanne Capper, Fan Man-yee, and Channon Christian and Chris Newsome

April 28, 2020

Torture is on the table and we want to put up a trigger warning for this week's episode where we tell the horrific stories of the murders of Suzanne Capper, who was murdered by her so-called friends, then Fan Man-yee, in the famous Hello Kitty murder, and finally, Channon Christian and Chris Newsom…